Bethany was still staring at him flabbergasted. Her heart was pounding at the words she had been waiting years to hear, but her brain panicking, trying to wrap around his words.
“You want...Roland what? You can’t...you can’t be serious?!”
Was he just looking to sleep with them all? To date them...that was impossible.
“No...no your not being serious. You can’t be. You can’t date all of us. That’s...that’s wrong. And mean! What if one of us loves you more? What if...what if you decide to pick just one and dump the rest? No...no Roland no.”
She pulled her hand out of his and started to cry, “Why are you doing this me? You know I’ve loved you since seventh grade! You know I’ve never even kissed a boy! Why would you hurt me like this? You come in here...all cute and tell me you love me...but only if you can fuck other girls?!”
She swore. It wasn’t often she did but it held weight coming from her tongue. The tears rolled down her cheeks, staining her silk top.
“I don’t want your sloppy seconds or thirds. I don’t want to be some harem girl to fill whatever twisted fantasy you have Roland. I thought you were better than that. I thought you knew me better than that.”
Her bottom lip shook and she stared at her hands in her lap, crying.
Downstairs the girls were even talking about it.
“You think Beth will like it?”
“No,” Andrea shook her head flatly, “she’s going to hate it. He has his work cut out for him.”
“He’s been in love with him longer than any of us. She hasn’t even held a boys hand,” Ashley pointed out, “she’s always hoped he would come to love her. Out of all of us, she was the last to make that promise.”
“Yeah trying to convince Beth that none of us could have him because we all loved him was rough,” Lela nodded, “and she grew up catholic so...”
“So?” Tia raised an eyebrow.
“So poliamorous relationships are sin to Catholics aren’t they?” Lela asked, “they believe in a man and women. Not a man and six women.”
“Or two women,” Tia teased, kissing Ashley as they snuggled together at the end of the bed, “so you think Beth is going to lose it?”
Lela and Andrea nodded.
“I think Roland can make it work,” Veronica offered softly. She looked around at them, “he convinced all of us right? Even though at least two of us are straight.”
She stared at Andrea who nodded.
“I never thought I’d agree to this but I love him too much to turn him down. And if it works it works. I think he can make Beth see.”
“How?”
“How did he convince you Andrea?”
She blushed fiercely, “He...took my virginity. But he gave me the choice.”
Veronica smiled, “he gave me what I wanted in that car. After that...I couldn’t say no. He made me feel so...”
“Alive?” Lela finished grinning, “he gave me something like that too. I’ve never felt so close to him.”
Tia nodded, “same. He took mine too Andrea.”
Ashley made a face, “Am I the only one whose had nothing to give?”
“Had butt sex yet Ashley?” Lela asked.
“Once but...”
“Tried oral?” Veronica countered.
“Well sort of. I’ve never, you know, deepthroated. Never seen Roland’s size though.”
The girls grinned and Tia squeezed her, “give him that. Then you’ll know what we mean.”
“Closer than ever.”
All of them nodded in agreement.