DarkDreamer9110
Star
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2013
Cassie smiled as Ellie verified that her dysphoria had been a lifelong thing. When Ellie walked over to Dusty and hugged him, Cassie noticed Sabrina step forward as well, handing Dusty her business card with a smile and nod.
The session continued, with the only notable moment being when (inevitably, Cassie realized in hindsight) someone had brought up the question of trans people (particularly trans women) in sports. Cassie had sighed, and then decided to open up some eyes.
"1936 Berlin Olympics. Helen Stephens and Stella Walsh, two female athletes, were subjected to gender verification exams under accusations they were male. Stephens was found to be biologically female. But she was hit with the accusations anyways because how dare a woman be so good. The fact is, people pretend there's this acceptable range of female performance and body types, but it's all just misogyny. Everyone's different. And you can't tell me that naturally tall basketball players don't have a "biological advantage." But nobody bans tall people from basketball for being tall. It's all about standards and control. People love to discriminate for all kinds of BS reasons.
"Walsh's case is more complicated; she was intersex. And interestingly, there's actually a recent case where that issue is relevant. Caster Semenya. She's intersex, and look what they demanded of her, that, after having already been cleared back in 2009 to compete as a female after she was forced to undergo sex testing, now there's some bullshit law saying her testosterone level is too high.
"Finally, Lia Thomas. People really threw a fit about her. You want to claim "biological advantage," take a look at her time before and after and then eat your fucking words. She's not standing out in her times at the top of the charts in the women's competitions.
"Let's be honest: "biological advantage" is used as a shield for transmisogyny, racism, and the continued efforts by cisnormative standards to police women's bodies and identities. It's all BS. You want to enforce specific criteria for sports eligibility, go ahead and write up minimum and maximum ranges for every physical attribute for every sport. And then enforce those for everyone. Stop acting like it's about "fairness" when it's about oppression, when it's about policing people who are different."
The session continued, with the only notable moment being when (inevitably, Cassie realized in hindsight) someone had brought up the question of trans people (particularly trans women) in sports. Cassie had sighed, and then decided to open up some eyes.
"1936 Berlin Olympics. Helen Stephens and Stella Walsh, two female athletes, were subjected to gender verification exams under accusations they were male. Stephens was found to be biologically female. But she was hit with the accusations anyways because how dare a woman be so good. The fact is, people pretend there's this acceptable range of female performance and body types, but it's all just misogyny. Everyone's different. And you can't tell me that naturally tall basketball players don't have a "biological advantage." But nobody bans tall people from basketball for being tall. It's all about standards and control. People love to discriminate for all kinds of BS reasons.
"Walsh's case is more complicated; she was intersex. And interestingly, there's actually a recent case where that issue is relevant. Caster Semenya. She's intersex, and look what they demanded of her, that, after having already been cleared back in 2009 to compete as a female after she was forced to undergo sex testing, now there's some bullshit law saying her testosterone level is too high.
"Finally, Lia Thomas. People really threw a fit about her. You want to claim "biological advantage," take a look at her time before and after and then eat your fucking words. She's not standing out in her times at the top of the charts in the women's competitions.
"Let's be honest: "biological advantage" is used as a shield for transmisogyny, racism, and the continued efforts by cisnormative standards to police women's bodies and identities. It's all BS. You want to enforce specific criteria for sports eligibility, go ahead and write up minimum and maximum ranges for every physical attribute for every sport. And then enforce those for everyone. Stop acting like it's about "fairness" when it's about oppression, when it's about policing people who are different."