@True Grave -- I believe you can take another shot in the same post.
The rules say that if you score. You go again. While we're on the subject of rules-- Can we say rolling a 10 counts as a bounce back/ reroll ? There are only 9 cups.
Actually that’s probably an easier way to keep track. Rather than saying the corresponding # is gone we just reduce the roll to 1-9 then 1-8 and so on.