Overall, it sounds as though it's a choice between numbers and conservation, as well as speed (option 1) or overall power with crippling and deceptive combat methods (option 2). Given the choice, based on the capabilities and resources provided, I'd go with option one, but either way, both sides have their pros and cons to them. I.E The Interdictor has LESS firepower in contrast despite being the same size as an Imperial-Class I (about 1/2 to compensate for the added gravity wells that disrupt the hyperdrives in other ships that get caught in range) while on the other hand, the Frigate as well isn't as greatly armed, but they house medical bays which seem to either not be mentioned in the star destroyers, or just don't exist.
My choice is option one, but with how I set up Logan, being from Kuat and all, he'd probably be more comfortable with option two. So you see, it's a toss-up, but I'm not bothered by what is chosen in the end.