Patreon LogoYour support makes Blue Moon possible (Patreon)

Good and realistic(-ish) incest ideas?

Dr Bellwright

Dr Bellwright

Doctor
Supporter
Joined
Apr 27, 2019
Location
London
I have nothing against incest in roleplays, but every time I see it in a kink list or request thread, I get a "writer's block", I actually can't imagine realistic Parent/Child or Sibling/Sibling scenario. So I thought, why don't I ask my fellow perverts – did you had a memorable setup for an incest roleplay? Maybe in the works now or from the past.

Feel free to send me a PM message if you are want to stay anonymous.
 
Hihi~

So... for me, the best incest rps are based in psychological horror. A love too deep that it turns dark and twisted. A moral denial turned into a secret obsession that finally physically manifests with the passion of a violent, all consuming force of a brutal rape... all the while whispering and grunting words of endearment in mc ear as she enters subspace.

I like a balance of extremes that can only be mentally stimulated with that kind of incest rp~

Hope this helps! 💕
 
I guess in the end it is usually far fetched but I do know what you mean by realistic-ish as I tend to like the same thing. Some basic plots below.

Incest by Accident

Son is at a party, blindfolded. Stripper comes in provides some kind of sexual service. Turns out she is his sister or mother. No one knows of course. Maybe the son and relative find out later.

Man in 40's donated sperm when he was in his late teens/early 20's. He is now seeing a woman half his age who is young enough to be his daughter... I actually see this one as very realistic. Perhaps at some point she becomes ill and they have to have blood tests and then they find out! What do they do after establishing this romance??

I have a more complex and less realistic idea about a sex ed class gone wrong.

To overcome grief

One idea I love is a mother and daughter who live together but have grown apart. One day the daughter is watching retro porn and recognizes the woman in the clip as her mother. She is offended and yet turned on. Long story short she confronts her mother and over discussions they start becoming innocently physical. Of course that doesn't last... The mother knows it is wrong but likes that their bond is repairing itself. Given how common sex work is now I feel the basic premise is plausible.

The old chestnut. Mother dies, father lonely and depressed. Daughter wants to help...

Training

Could be a mother who was a stripper/whore teaching her daughter etc. Doesn't have to be direct incest involving sex but definitely blurring the lines.

Less plausible but I love it - An older sister or Aunt has always wondered why their very cute and polite relative has never had a girlfriend. One day she accidentally walks in on him in the shower and sees he has a micro penis and everything makes sense. She forces him to open up and realizes that she must train him to be subservient and useful to women in other ways.

Incest by family tradition.

This one is more a case of incest being part of the family tradition. Once a certain age the sibling knows they will be initiated into sex by their parent. It could have added elements of cults etc.

Not quite incest but blurry

Not between relatives but similar in my opinion. I have always loved the idea of the older man with younger woman. Perhaps this man was a family friend and when she was a kid they would go out for ice cream and the zoo etc. So she is like a daughter to him. Years later he is much older and so is she. You can put various spins on it, one idea was that when she was still young he moved away. Years later she is 18 and looking for a sugar daddy, they start communicating on the site but after years apart don't realize who each other is. They meet up and the pennies start falling.

A variation could be he goes into a brothel and finds her working there.
 
Those are all great examples, Dirty Fingers, I especially like the second one in "Incest by Accident!" Mind if I coin it?
 
Incest isn't a particular kink of mine, or something I go looking for, but one I will write if it suits the story or theme. Incest just for Incest's sake holds no attraction for me.

I've only ever written one; currently on hiatus; per the outline below, with what I think is a memorable plot setup. The sibling's incestuous relationship isn't a driver of the plot, but incorporated as a natural extension of the torment inflicted upon them.

"Psychologically damaged by physical and emotional abused received as children adopted brother and sister, Adam and Eve, had only each other to depend upon when they escaped the home of their bible-thumping, evangelic Foster Parents. A few years later, closer than ever, and with both working menial jobs in a different state, the old voices and visions come flooding back when on the television news they see their Step-Father, his City's long-term Police Chief, nominated as preferred Senatorial Candidate for his State's Republican Party.

Frightened that a position of such status and importance will provide him the means to bring about the much talked of Armageddon, sending them to burn in the depths of Hell for eternity, they need to take action to avoid his world-ending wrath, but how can the duo be expected to be able to face down one who is virtually Omnipotent? Only by thinning out his blue-uniformed protective Army first, with the added benefit of pissing him off in the process, do they even stand a chance.

But, how many will be enough and who is stalking them as the cop-killings grow ever more frequent. Friend, or foe?"
 
Damn, Dirty Fingers, several of those sound almost verbatim like a few of my ideas from over on Elliquiy forums.
 
Dirty Fingers said:
lol did you ever get any of them off the ground?
Click to expand...

Actually yes (it was a version of the Accidental Incest story where frat boy brother gets a present from his fraternity bros, namely a blindfolded stripper to suck him off for his birthday and it turns out to be his sister who ran away years ago, making him to have to keep his mouth shut about it to avoid an insanely embarrassing situation but only slightly worse than letting her do that to him and find out later), but it didn't last long. My partner wasn't quite as verbose as I was so it ended up being a poor match of literacy level.
 
Mathim said:
Actually yes (it was a version of the Accidental Incest story where frat boy brother gets a present from his fraternity bros, namely a blindfolded stripper to suck him off for his birthday and it turns out to be his sister who ran away years ago, making him to have to keep his mouth shut about it to avoid an insanely embarrassing situation but only slightly worse than letting her do that to him and find out later), but it didn't last long. My partner wasn't quite as verbose as I was so it ended up being a poor match of literacy level.
Click to expand...

It sucks when that happens. Even a fairly basic premise like that one can be made into something exciting even if it's short term.

Scenario's like that or being forced into a situation through circumstance rather than by someone else tend to be more interesting to me than the usual non con/rapey stuff.
 
Dirty Fingers said:
It sucks when that happens. Even a fairly basic premise like that one can be made into something exciting even if it's short term.

Scenario's like that or being forced into a situation through circumstance rather than by someone else tend to be more interesting to me than the usual non con/rapey stuff.
Click to expand...

Yeah, it came to me as a pretty much one-shot type of formula but I don't usually intend for a game to have a definite end point so I always like to try to make it go on indefinitely if I can.

I know it's not realistic but there's a hentai anime where a board game has a mind of its own, and it makes a son and mother have sex, then in the next episode it does that to the daughter with the son. I wanted to expand that idea into an entire family becoming the son's harem but I doubt anyone would want to play that many characters in one game like that.
 
*cracks knuckles*

Specifically for a mother/son pairing, I tend to go for the dynamic of a young single mother developing a covert incestuous relationship with her son before it delves into legit physical incest. With siblings, one is usually unhinged and extremely possessive of their brother/sister which leads to the eventual incest, sometimes utilizing the whole covert incest thing in the beginning. For siblings, I almost always make them twins, I guess because of an assumedly stronger bond.

Recently, I've had a pairing in mind that hasn't been fully fleshed out enough for an RP or solo writing piece. Basically, half-siblings that are both outsiders in their own family. They weren't raised together, but there's a vague familiarity from having met sporadically a few times throughout their lives. The contrast between his volatile personality and well-known drug addiction compared to her silently suffering from depression and an eating disorder is a dynamic I'd really like to dive into. But that's pretty dark though, so I'm not sure if it's something you'd take inspiration from if that's not the tone you're looking for.
 
Last edited:
I just don't go for the incest family or the no hesitation, no remorse thing.
It is much more interesting to have them not even realize they are attracted, and resist it when they do realize. It can be a TWD scenario, or Southern Gothic craziness type.
It is easier to justify with more distant relationships.
 
RedRose said:
I just don't go for the incest family or the no hesitation, no remorse thing.
It is much more interesting to have them not even realize they are attracted, and resist it when they do realize. It can be a TWD scenario, or Southern Gothic craziness type.
It is easier to justify with more distant relationships.
Click to expand...

Never done an incest family one although I have thought about it. I think you can still have conflict, the person who is nearing the time of their "rite of passage" knowing it is wrong from what they have learned at school, online etc but also knowing it is such an important part of their family tradition and culture. To me that is interesting. That they go through with it even though they are in two minds about it all. Even more interesting would be that character have a discussion about it with their opposite gender parent.

I like to get in characters heads.
 
I almost forgot, I read a hentai manga a while back where as teenagers, a tomboy sister used to get her friend to help her tie her brother up and take his pants off to torment him, poking and doing other things to his penis just as experiments. Then as they got older, he decided to turn the tables on her.
 
Dirty Fingers said:
Never done an incest family one although I have thought about it. I think you can still have conflict, the person who is nearing the time of their "rite of passage" knowing it is wrong from what they have learned at school, online etc but also knowing it is such an important part of their family tradition and culture. To me that is interesting. That they go through with it even though they are in two minds about it all. Even more interesting would be that character have a discussion about it with their opposite gender parent.

I like to get in characters heads.
Click to expand...
True, this would be interesting. I've just seen so many incest families RP being absolutely bland...
 
Well I've got a pretty interesting idea for one I'm trying to get a group together on, where home invaders force the family to perform on each other for their entertainment.
 
Not incest but I feel there is some overlap. Themes where the parent has sex with their offspring's partner, whether it be because the offspring's partner comes onto them or for some other reason which could vary. Same with one sibling having sex with their siblings partner.
 
Dirty Fingers said:
Not incest but I feel there is some overlap. Themes where the parent has sex with their offspring's partner, whether it be because the offspring's partner comes onto them or for some other reason which could vary. Same with one sibling having sex with their siblings partner.
Click to expand...

Kind of like one of my ideas where a brother and his girlfriend are both loved by the sister, and it becomes a three-person loving relationship.
 
Mathim said:
Kind of like one of my ideas where a brother and his girlfriend are both loved by the sister, and it becomes a three-person loving relationship.
Click to expand...

Cool. I see it as somewhat incest-ish as family members are sharing something sexual even if it isn't directly. Same as those stories you hear about a husband leaving their wife to family member when they die.
 
On another site I have a pretty good incest-story going on, a father x daughter (mother died while giving birth), where the father is a writer, who along the lines of John Norman's Gor-series, has written a series of books. In the latest installment, the book he's currently writing (although apart from references to said book, there will be no exerpts) has as plot the main protagonist buys a young girl at auction, who turns out to be his own flesh and blood. And in the story, the father-figure is going to introduce his daughter to the same treatment as will happen in the book.
 
Caligula said:
With siblings, one is usually unhinged and extremely possessive of their brother/sister which leads to the eventual incest, sometimes utilizing the whole covert incest thing in the beginning. For siblings, I almost always make them twins, I guess because of an assumedly stronger bond.
Click to expand...

I had a similar constellation in the backstory of one of my characters. It was male identical twins who were very close to each other. One of them was jealous of an uncle with whom the twin spent too much time. When the twins were studying, living together in a flat the jealous twin seduced the other one while they were both drunk. The seduced twin said they should be reasonable and not to this again, but the other one couldn't accept that and seduced him again and again. But when they had finished studying the jealous one became furious when the other one dropped him and married a woman. The jealous twin was heartbroken left the country, became a really violent brute who murdered and robbed people and was very feared.
So it was also a case of someone being possessive about his twinbrother.

On „normal“ boards (with sidewide plots, so no 1x1 roleplay) the staff demanded to edit the twincest out. That happened on boards with 3/3/3 ratings, where it was O.K. to describe the most brutal murders in every detail, but to have non-violent twincest in your character's backstory was a no-go.
I was pondering to roleplay a younger version of this character, looking for someone who plays the other twin. So that we roleplay the student years of the twins. But after getting so many appalled reactions for twincest in the backstory I rather wanted to spare myself further hassle and doubted that I would find anybody who wants to roleplay such a plot. I suppose that would be only possible on boards like Bluemoon.

I also had a character who was a vampire who had been born in the 18th century, and he kept track of the human family members. The vampire invited a direct descendant of his brother to the family residence. So the vampire was that young male human's Greatgrandgrandgrand...uncle. It was planned that the vampire falls in love with the young man, seduces him and turns him later on.
I started roleplaying this on a Googledoc, unfortunately the roleplay buddy ghosted on me. I would have liked to roleplay that with someone else but didn't find anybody.
The characters weren't that closely related. Even so most people didn't want to know me any more as soon as I suggested such a pairing – when I looked for 1x1 roleplay buddies on a recource site. That's one of the reasons why I'm back on a board where people are more open-minded for taboo-pairings.
 
I have a couple of different incest scenarios in mind where the brother is shared between the sister and another unrelated girl. Like a mix and match kind of thing. Just sounds hotter to me, like a best of both worlds kind of thing. But it's hard to find partners who are willing to play two characters while I play one.
 
Not as exciting as direct relatives but if you want realism than cousins being married to each other etc is historically accurate.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom