Robert's heart broke at her tears. He held her close. It was an awful dilemma, continue in a lie or break her heart. He steeled himself against the dread he was feeling. He knew the situation would get worse for the waiting, not better. he comforted her and told her he would wait, but in his heart he knew it was wrong. He forced a smile and then a grin, doing his level best to bring back he joy. In his heart though he knew, he could never steal her from her father like that. If they were to be married it would be with her father's permission, and full knowledge of what he was doing. They walked back down the hill and joined the family for a wonderful dinner. After dinner, he and Cornelia again spent the evening on the porch, kissed before bed and drifted off to sleep, at least Cornelia did.
The next morning Robert and her father left for work. Robert gave her a longer than normal kiss fearing it might be the last, but praying that it wouldn't be.
As they made the long ride to Richmond, Robert interrupted the small talk and said "Sir there is something I must tell you, or I will have no honor as a man. First let me say that I love your daughter with all my heart soul and mind." Her father, relizing this was serious business stopped the buggy to listen. " I would never do anything to hurt her, but as things stand now I cannot marry her." Her father frowned. "Why son?" he asked. he swallowed hard and said."Your permission was obtained with out your full knowledge of the facts. I was as I said a wounded soldier. I served honorably in the war, but I was a British conscript taken against my will by the King's Army to fight in America. I was as you say a "redcoat". A fact that pains me greatly having seen first hand the good I was fighting against. This is a great country, wronged greatly by my people, and the King. I ask you now for your forgiveness, for my sake and for your daughter's for she loves me and begged me not to do this until we were married. But sir I could deceive you no longer , and could not steal your daughter from you, having already contributed to the cause that killed your son." He hung his head. " I will understand if you cannot forgive me, and if that be the case I will leave you here and now and leave your family in peace. But if you can forgive me, I promise to be a good husband, and son, and patriot, for I have come to love this land."
He couldn't look up to face the man he had so badly deceived. He waited for the words, he feared would come, the hate and revulsion and rejection. Finally after a long pause her father spoke. "You.........are a man of honor, and love, and kindness, and good. A strong man, both of body and moral fiber. You are the the things we fought the war to keep alive, the things my son died to keep alive. You are not a redcoat. and I am proud to have you for my daughters husband, and proud to call you a son. Raise your head young man, you have nothing to be ashamed of. We have work to do. I will explain this to my wife this evening. Please leave that duty to me."