Hatter didn't lift his blade, didn't shift his feet. He just watched the way her breath caught, and the way her dagger, so steady a moment ago, drifted, ever so slightly, as her eyes faltered.
"No one made me into this."
"
I know," he said softly. "
You chose to come here, chose to follow a trail lined in red paint and half-truths. Chose to carry knives instead of questions." His voice wove in close, each word a little sharper than the last, not in volume but in precision. He took measured, smooth, unthreatening step, just enough to make her feet adjust. Just enough to draw her attention back toward the glint of the sword still low in his grip.
"
You're not her?" he echoed, not mocking, but testing. "
Then why does Wonderland still reach for you when you pass?"
As if to interject its own answer to Hatter's question, the air fluttered its tongue like a trilling flutist. A frown appeared, hovering midair just above Alice's shoulder. It was wide and upside-down, like a cracked smile trying to stand on its head. The expression was familiar, if inside-out, and it hovered in silence for exactly three seconds before rotating, slowly and exactly impossibly, until it flipped itself upright. The corners curled upward.
"
Oh, lovely," came the drawl, lilting and smug and half-fond. "
Still wearing your guilt like a borrowed coat, I see. A bit snug in the shoulders, but very slimming."
The grin brightened. A paw, striped, silken, and too long in the fingers, materialized just beneath it, wagging one claw like a lecture pointer. "
You're walking like a lie in borrowed shoes, darling. Not quite sure how your heels fit into someone else's story, are you?"
Hatter didn't react, didn't even glance toward the grin. He stepped again, just a half-step to the side, making sure he was always on her edge, always in her peripheral. His blade dipped, then rose again by a finger's breadth. A rhythm formed in the movement, the kind that implied it could break at any moment. He wanted her mind divided. He needed it.
"
She said you'd come here as a knife," Hatter murmured, almost to himself, "
but you're breaking like a mirror."
"
I like her better broken," Cheshire offered cheerfully, rotating lazily in place like a carousel in a power outage, "
more interesting patterns." The air behind Alice fluttered like paper lifting in heat. "
You're thinking of the table now, aren't you?" the Cat purred, voice curling like smoke. "
Of laughter and sugar and the rain that tasted like raspberries. You're trying not to. But it's there. Just a little too much light at the edge of the memory."
"
She told you that wasn't real," Hatter said, drawing her eyes back to him. "
And you believed her."
A pause. Not long, but long enough for the war room to breathe.
The grin brightened. "
Don't worry, love. You don't have to remember. You just have to doubt."
That was the trick. Not to crack her, not yet. Just to make her wonder if the Queen had already lost. The silence thickened, dense as clotted cream. For a moment, it seemed like even Wonderland itself leaned in to listen—rafters sighed, vines twitched, and the moonlight bent just enough to spotlight the three of them like actors trapped on an unwritten page. Hatter's gaze never left her. The blue in his eyes pulsed, still too bright, still off by some subtle, aching degree, and he shifted his weight with the same ease as breathing. His blade dipped once more, then rose slowly and deliberately, until the point hovered level with her chest.
Alice's eyes naturally tracked it. That was all he needed. He lifted it higher, not enough to threaten, just enough to pull her gaze upward.
And there it was. Hovering at the very apex of the sword's tip, spinning slowly in weightless defiance of gravity, was that grin.
Wide.
Unblinking.
Too
white.
"
Peekaboo," said the Cheshire Cat's mouth alone, voice gleeful and patient at once. "
Now we're playing!"
The sword held steady beneath the hovering grin like it was offering the expression up as tribute. Hatter's voice came low, from just beneath it. "
You want to look away," he said, "
but you don't. Because you know if you do, the memory might vanish again."
"
Or multiply!" added Cheshire, upside-down once more, spinning midair like a coin on its final edge. "
You are terribly prone to recursion when you're stressed, dear." The Cat's mouth expanded into a too-large smile, stretching until it nearly eclipsed the blade entirely. For a breath, it looked like the sword had become a tongue depressor for a grin too big to be part of any sane anatomy. "
She's remembering in loops," the Cat cooed, "
poor thing doesn't even know which parts she's made up to protect herself! I love watching humans do this. It's like drowning on dry land."
Hatter didn't smile. He moved again, softly, a quarter step closer, like a musician advancing toward the next note of a song only he could hear. "
You don't have to believe me," he challenged, blade still poised, eyes locked on hers, "
but look me in the eye, just once, and tell me you never danced on a table in the rain."
The sword did not waver and the grin hung above it like punctuation at the end of a riddle. The air pulsed between them, and the blade held steady while the grin above it shimmered faintly, its curve twitching at the corners as if resisting laughter—or preparing to devour it.
Hatter's voice dropped, quieter than before, but clear enough to cut glass. "
Drink me." The tip of his sword started to tick back and forth like a metronome.
The grin quirked. A familiar counterpoint followed like velvet and venom. "
Eat me."
A pause.
"
Drink me," Hatter said again, just a hair sharper, the edge of a second hand ticking forward.
"
Eat me," Cheshire purred, perfectly timed, perfectly cruel.
"
Drink me."
"
Eat me."
"
Drink me."
"
Eat me."
Tick.
"
Drink me."
Tock.
"
Eat me."
Tick.
Tock.
Tick.
Tock.
Tick.
Tock. Each line fell like a pendulum, too precise for comfort, too deliberate to ignore.
Cheshire's grin pulsed in rhythm with the chant, bobbing slightly at the tip of Hatter's blade, casting a crescent-shaped shadow across Alice's chest. Somewhere, in the rafters, something metal clicked in sympathy, a rusted gear that had no business turning anymore echoing impolitely.
"
Drink me," Hatter said again, softly this time, almost kindly.
"
Eat me," the Cat whispered. Not a taunt now, but a secret.
The rhythm slowed, then held its breath. And then the room went very, very still, waiting to see which of them she'd hear in her bones.