Patreon LogoYour support makes Blue Moon possible (Patreon)

The Wrong Sister (Mykhaila & jayplay2)

M

Mykhaila

Guest
Emma Jameson knew it was late but she couldn't sleep so she decided to get up and climb in the shower. She knew about an hour ago her older sister Alyson had gotten up from her bed and slipped out of her room, probably to meet her boyfriend or another of her lovers. Emma didn't agree with how her sister was with boys, she was too loose and never seemed to realize that she could hurt people.

Emma was a virgin, keeping herself pure for the right time. There were several of the boys that her sister slept with that would see her and mistake her for her sister. She knew well it was because there were few differences between her and Aly. For one, Aly was only three years older than Emma who had just turned fifteen a month and a half ago, another Aly was actually a little shorter, Emma turned out to sprout in height passed her sister over the last couple of years.

Other differences were breast size, Emma's were B's though if they kept growing they would be C's soon enough, but Aly had C's already. Emma's hair was kept longer than her sisters, the length falling down to mid back while Aly's was shoulder blade length. Other than that, their eyes were similar, their cheek bones similar. If their hair was up as Emma's was now from the back she looked just like Aly.

Since Emma was just climbing into the shower, the water warm and spilling over her, she had her hair up which was part of her ritual. Her back was to the door as she let her head tilt back, the spray from the shower head causing rivulets of water to slide over her soft skin, down her breasts and lower still.

The small shower, barely large enough to fit two only had the one entrance which left her backside facing the entrance while she relished the water and hummed softly to herself. The only light on in the house belonged to the bathroom she shared with her sister, it actually was located with doors from both of the girls' bedrooms. She thought for a moment she heard a sound from her sisters room but shook it off. It might just be her sister sneaking back in early, she thought to herself.
 
James Montgomery walk into Aly's to see if she was home. he was 18 years old. he had brown eyes, short black hair, and gray eyes. james was about 6 feet tall. on a good night (which is all the time) his dick was about 14 ins. long and 3 ins. wide. he did not know about Aly's little sister because she never talk about her when they was out on dates. he was thinking about Aly that night. he was looking around in her room seeing that the light was on. james was a one guy girl. he never slept with other girls but Aly. in fact Aly was James's first girl. he hears the water running in the shower and slowly open the bathroom door and start to close it slowly and with a smile on his face he starts to take off his clothes and look at Emma's back thinking that she was Aly's back.
 
Emma began humming softly as she turned, her eyes were closed so she was completely unaware that she wasn't alone anymore. Her head tilted back under the water as she lifted her arms to begin loosening her hair from the bands in them so that she could let her hair down. The sight presented to her sister's boyfriend was one of full breasts, pert nipples and a shaved pussy.

Once her hair was loose, she turned again without opening her eyes so she could make certain her hair got completely soaked before she could work the shampoo into it. She had no idea someone was standing there behind her as her eyes opened and she sighed softly. It felt so good under the water that she wasn't in any hurry to get out of the shower so wasn't rushing to finish.
 
james starts to open the shower door slowly and got in with emma thinking that she was aly. he had soap in his hands and start to rub her breasts slowly and kiss her neck. " hey Aly I didn't think that you would been up this late." he smiled as his hand runs down her body feeing emma soft skin on his finger tips. just the touch of her skin was just Enough for him to start to get hard. his dick starts to get hard under her legs. he wanted to take her now but the shower was too small for them to do anything. he was just lucky that he had enough room to fit in the shower with her.
 
Emma still humming was taken completely unaware when she felt hands slip around her and cover her breasts. Feeling those hands rub her breasts, she gasped, her nipples hardening under the hands. A blush covered her cheeks as she felt something hard against her backside and along her legs and the lips on her neck. Hearing the voice that sounded, she sputtered nervously, "I..I'm not Aly..."

She turned her head to look back, knowing she should tell him to get out, to stop touching her. She opened her mouth to say something but when she saw him she found her eyes widening in surprise. Aly had never mentioned that she was involved with someone who was black. "Y...you shouldn't be here," she added, though there wasn't much conviction in her tone, her blush was brighter and she knew her body betrayed her as she pushed back against him, arching into his hands.
 
James was surprise when he herd Emma voice and not Aly. " who are you?" she looks some what like Aly. he started to put two and two together and see that she was Aly little sister. " I am sorry that I am in here with you." his mind was telling him to go but is other head was telling him to go for it. it was a hard for him to go, Emma look like a younger version of Aly. he said in his head. " just one kiss, if I feel something then I stay, but If I don't I will go." he said that over and over in his head as he felt her soft skin on his body then he put his hand on her face and started to kiss her.
 
"Emma." She replied softly to the question he asked, still trying to tell herself to make him leave but before she could say anything more, his lips were on hers. A surprised gasp left her lips which parted innocently and after a moments hesitation she found herself responding to the kiss tentatively. A soft moan escaped her throat, she had never been kissed before.

It was such a strange sensation but it sent waves of pleasure through her body, causing her to move her backside against him with what seemed like a natural reaction. Her hand lifted of it's own accord to go up behind his head as she stood there kissing him back, her innocence clear in each reaction. After several moments, she drew her mouth from his to breathe out, "Who are you...? This... This isn't... right..." No conviction fired her words.
 
He knew that emma was right that this was not right but his body felt like it was. he put his arms around her and look into her eyes. he wanted to leave but it was something in that kiss that told him to stay with her. he never felt a kiss like that from Aly. it was very diffent. he wanted to kiss her again, James just wanted her but he didn't want to cheat on Aly. his body didn't want to move it wanted to stay with Emma. "my name is James. I am Aly boyfriend." his voice was a little breaky how could he say that he was Aly boyfriend if he was in the shower with her sister. he kiss her on her neck again feeling her soft skin on his lips. he was fighting a losing battle in which his body was winning.
 
Emma shuddered as James' lips went to her neck again, she found herself closing her eyes and leaning back against him, even as she spoke words that she knew wouldn't make the male behind her happy. Even as she knew she should still make him go. She also realized she had to keep as quiet as she could or she would wake her parents and then she would be in big trouble. "I hate to break it to you James," her hand behind his head slid around to his cheek, "Aly isn't loyal... she never has been..."

Drawing in a deep breath, she turned, the small space causing her to find herself in even more trouble or temptation when she felt that same hardness that had been against her ass and down her mid thighs now against her lower stomach and pussy instead as she looked James in the eye, gasping at the sensation. Her blush making her cheeks crimson as she stepped back as much as she could needing the space to think clearly. "You really should go James..." Her confusion was evident, the innocence warring with the lust she had never felt before that he was invoking in her...
 
James move his lips away from Emma's soft neck and looked at her. " what do you mean that Aly isn't loyal?" he look at her in disbelief but his arms was still around her body. as emma turned around james got a eye full of her body and a smiled was on his face but he start to shake his head to get out of his fantasy he was having. James's dick was hitting her lower stomach as he was in fantasy for alittle wile. he step back trying to clam his body down and getting his mind back in shape. " I should go...but my body is not letting me move." he looks at her as he was fighting his body's needs as his dick was fully hard and up.
 
Emma saw the disbelief on James' face and shook her head, using the conversation to focus as she backed up as far as she could, her hands on his chest to push him away but she didn't push hard. "She's not here, James. If she was loyal she would be. She has never been a one man type of girl." She spoke honestly.

When he said his body wouldn't let him move, she shook her head, "I'm not like her, James... I've never..." She blushed, she couldn't even continue to speak, her gaze went to the wall of the shower as she made the admission. "I can't... I won't be a conquest."
 
James looked at Emma then start to look down feeling that she was being honest. he started to think why aly was not here and not in her bed. " you are her sister so you would know her more then I do." he looks up at her and smiled a little at her. " I know you are not like her that is a good thing Emma." he put his hand on her face and rub it softly. "you wont be a conquest. you will find someone who loves you for you." he smiled trying hide the hurt in his heart then he starts to open the shower door. "well let me get out of here then. I don't want a girl like you to get in trouble with your parents. and I am sorry for walking in the shower." he starts to pick up his clothes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom