Patreon LogoYour support makes Blue Moon possible (Patreon)

Star trek - Star Wars or Trek Wars

Joined
Jun 28, 2009
I was thinking of a possible trek wars thread
baring that
a star trek thread
baring that
a star wars thread

if you do not know what Trek Wars is its a Star trek Star wars cross over
 
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" rel="nofollow" href="http://i466.photobucket.com/albums/rr29/okarola/Star_Trek_vs_Star_Wars_2.jpg">http://i466.photobucket.com/albums/rr29 ... Wars_2.jpg</a><!-- m -->
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" rel="nofollow" href="http://i466.photobucket.com/albums/rr29/okarola/Star_Trek_vs_Star_Wars_1.jpg">http://i466.photobucket.com/albums/rr29 ... Wars_1.jpg</a><!-- m -->

for star wars io was thinking between episod 3 and 4
for trek somewhere after voyager
 
Where the hell do you get your info?

Star Wars hyperdrive allows them to traverse the breath of their galaxy in weeks. Star Trek can't even do that within their own quadrants.
 
Maybe because they are larger? Would you really expect a mile long Star Destroyer to turn as quickly as the 16 meter X-wing?
 
So?

Out turning a star wars vessel isn't that great an achievement. They'll just get blasted to little bits by any one of the star wars impressive weapons batteries.

Troop transport ships out gun star trek vessels.
 
What the hell movies have you watched?

Only ships I've not seen get consistently hit have all been piloted by named characters.
 
Quite clearly you are ignorant of Star Wars technology.

Sorry to say this; but the SWvsST debate ended almost a decade ago.
 
im not talking about what it should be able to do

i am talking about what it has ever actualy done on film or on a page
 
It's not even a comparison. Star Wars warships are much more capable. Star Trek ships are generally "General purpose" ships in terms of capability, not warships, at least in the Federation. Next Generation in particular, and later ships are not designed in the Federation to be vessels of war. They're ships of exploration, diplomacy, disaster relief, scientific research, even cargo transport at times. Most Star Wars ships aren't as versatile.

However, compare say, the Federation Heavy Cruiser, the iconic Enterprise, flagship of the Federation. Depending on source materials it has between 4-6 photon torpedo launchers, 10-14 phasers, of which usually 4 are point defense. Compare say, a Imperial Interdiction Cruiser, A, can pop vessels out of Lightspeed, which negates Star Trek's one advantage, at least in the original series where combat was conducted at Warp Speeds rather than sublight. If I recall rightly has some 30 or so heavy turbolaser batteries for anti-ship work and another 40 or so lighter ones for anti-fighter work, and has three squadrons of TIEs.

Heck, a TIE Bomber squadron exceeds the Federation CA in sheer firepower available.


Back to the original point though... depends on what you have up your sleeves for plot but I'd be willing to throw down in either Galaxy.
 
my idea was a single ship or planet is thrown into the other universe

sense everyone agrees trek would get wrecked in the star wars universe it would be a wars ship or planet in the trek universe.
 
Back
Top Bottom