Patreon LogoYour support makes Blue Moon possible (Patreon)

Hogwarts: The Upper Class - group CYOA (NSFW Warning)

Should Tabitha:

  • Knock, open the door, and join the group? She'll run into someone she knows eventually anyway.

  • Move along and try to find an empty compartment? Now isn't the time for reunions, and she really ne


Results are only viewable after voting.

heyitsjess

Supporter
Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2022
It was warm in London, had been all week, even for the very beginning of September. It wasn't unusual for some of summer to still linger in the south of England, but this year it had outstayed its welcome. The news had no solid explanation for the temperature, only that it should break "any day now".

The heat was even more oppressive at King's Cross station, or maybe it only seemedt to be, the closeness of the other travelers amplifying the temperature. This was one of the busier times for King's Cross, as boarding schools across the country began opening back up, and as vacationers reluctantly returned to their normal lives. Tabitha Ashwood was part of the first group.

Ready to start her twelfth year, the second-to-last in the British system, Tabitha was on her way back to her own school. As she watched the others; the kids her age and younger, she saw the same excitement, the same apprehension, the same nerves that she herself felt. That was where the similarities between herself and the rest ended though: they, you see, were muggles.

She watched as they went about their lives, moving and talking and laughing and generally pretending that they, in any way, mattered to the world. Tabitha couldn't say that she hated them, as such, but she did harbor a healthy disdain for the non-magic inhabitants of the world. They were like children: irritatingly naive and, to be fair, innocent in their own way. Well, the ones who weren't trying to fuck the whole planet up, at least. There was only so much that even magic could do to try to clean up the mess the muggles made and continued to make.

Tabitha watched them, green eyes looking out from under dark brown hair as she leaned against her luggage cart. They weren't looking at her, not directly, but it still wasn't safe yet. Even as Platform 9 began to thin out, she might still be noticed; seen suddenly disappearing into what should be a solid brick column. It took another five minutes before she felt safe enough.

The luggage cart was one of the smaller ones: Tabitha rarely brought much with her to Hogwarts. The school provided clothes and linens, food, and really any other daily needs. As such, all she had packed was underwear and a few "everyday" clothes. Due mostly to not being weighed down, the cart moved easily when she began, casually, pushing it in the general direction of the pillar. A quick glance to the side and behind confirmed that nobody was looking. In four steps she had gone from a casual stroll to an all-out sprint, aimed directly at a column of bricks.

The transition between Platform 9 and Platform 9¾ felt to her something like running through a short, black tunnel. For a few steps, Tabitha was surrounded by nothing: a dark abyss that probably wasn't entirely empty. Less than two seconds later, though, she emerged again onto a platform nearly identical to the one she had just left, except now, all the muggles were gone. These people, these were her people.

As she looked around, Tabitha saw faces that were new and old, and faces that might have been old but that she had forgotten. Parents were there to see-off their children, many of them for the first time. Did I look like that on my first day? Tabitha wondered, so fresh-faced, so eager, so… intimidated? She wouldn't admit, even to herself, that she had been terrified that first day. She had never been away from home, not without her parents. They had gone with her that first time, but never after.

But, this wasn't the first day, or at least, it wasn't that first day. No, this was year 12, the year in which, if you believed the rumors, things at Hogwarts… changed. The upper classmen, that is, the 12th and 13th year students, enjoyed certain privileges at the school, so the stories went. One thing was for sure: they had their own section of the dorm that was separated off from the rest, accessible only to them. That itself would probably be enough, but again, the gossip hinted at other, nebulous things.

"Help ye with yer bags there miss?" A man's voice from behind and to her right. Tabitha turned, pulled from her thoughts back into reality. A few feet from her stood a red-uniformed porter, smiling pleasantly.

"Hm? Oh. Oh, yes, I would appreciate that," Tabitha said, not quite making it to a "thank you", but getting more or less close. "There's not much so hopefully it won't be too much trouble." Maybe a little imperious, but not rude either.

"Won't be a problem," the porter assured her amiably. Not knowing what to say back, Tabitha gave a single nod, then kept walking.

The train was already parked, its red and black cars starting to fill with students. Tabitha never knew which car to board: they weren't reserved by house or year or, really, by anything. That sometimes created some… interesting situations. But, since she didn't know who was in which car, none was any better than another. She picked the third one, at random, stepping aboard, climbing the steps up, and ducking into the car.

The passageway was dark, though in a warm kind of way, with lighting that may, or may not, have been actual gas lamps: she had never checked or asked. Others were in the passageway, looking for seats in the private compartments. Most of the doors were shut, including the one just to her right, but she could hear voices from behind the door, and thought she could make out shadows playing over the frosted glass. As she listened, Tabitha was pretty sure she recognized someone. Getting reacquainted with friends and… not friends… was going to happen eventually. Was she ready for it already?

Should Tabitha:

A. Knock, open the door, and join the group? She'll run into someone she knows eventually anyway.

B. Move along and try to find an empty compartment? Now isn't the time for reunions, and she really needs to get herself back into the headspace of another, very different, school year.

Poll is above the story.
 
Poll Results New
Well, that was a lot closer than I thought it would be! Full disclosure, I'm running this on this site, and on BMRP's sister site Elliquiy at the same time. Since running them as separate stories would be way too much to handle, I'm putting polls on both sites and combining the results. On E, there were two additional votes for option A, and none for B, which puts total votes at 7 for A and 6 for B. Way closer than I expected! I'll have the next entry up shortly. Thanks everybody for voting!
 
Story New
Tabitha sucked in a breath, held it, then slowly let it out. Here we go, she thought, as she brought up her hand and gently knocked on the glass.

The voices on the other side stopped when she slid the door to the side, and Tabitha found herself met by two pairs of eyes. On her right was a boy, about her age, attractive but unfamiliar. She watched his eyebrows raise expectantly, and a small, unassuming smile tug his mouth upward at the corners. She liked the smile, she decided after half a second. The smile, and the eyes: brown and simple, expressive and also inquisitive. They asked who she was, what she was doing, what did she want. Tabitha wanted to look at those eyes some more, but the moment was abruptly, and loudly, broken.

"Tabitha!" Not quite a shriek, not quite a yell, but certainly louder than was necessary and comfortable for the confined space. Before she could react, Tabitha was nearly plowed over by an explosion of blonde hair, then wrapped in a bear hug.

"Hey, Maisie," Tabitha said, her own greeting much calmer than the one she'd received. This was the voice she had recognized: Maisie Trundle. They had known each other since their first year at Hogwarts, had in fact been best friends for a little while. Between then and now, though, they'd gone down different paths, orbited in separate circles, and found that their interests had diverged too far to really maintain a close friendship. At least, that was how Tabitha saw it. Maisie… not so much.

"It's so great to see you!" Maisie continued gushing. She at least had the good sense to let go of her victim after an almost-appropriate amount of time, though her hand still rested on Tabitha's arm. She turned to the boy in the cabin with them. "Edwin, this is my best friend, Tabitha Ashwood. Tab, this is Edwin Stormspire," she said, gesturing to each in turn.

"Hey," the boy, Edwin, said, and even in that single word, Tab could hear something of an accent. "But um… just call me Ed, alright?" There it was. The flat, slightly nasal American accent. If that hadn't proved his origin, Maisie confirmed it herself.

"Edwin is from the U.S.," she explained. "His parents moved to Nottingham over the summer. He transferred from a school over in America. Luckily their years line up with ours more or less so he was able to fit in really easily and…" Maisie stopped, suddenly realizing something. "Oh, I'm sorry. Edwin, you should probably be telling all of this." She grinned a little sheepishly. "Here, Tab, have a seat with me and we'll all catch up." Maisie sat on the bench seat opposite Edwin, scooted over to make room, then patted the cushion next to her.

"I… uh…" Tabitha hesitated. Maisie was a nice enough girl, if a bit easily excitable. She could be a lot to handle, especially when just getting back into the headspace of going back to school. Tabitha almost turned down the offer – almost – but those eyes. She looked back to Edwin and those damn eyes. "Um… alright," she finally agreed, and sat.

"So you're from the States?" Tabitha asked, trying to open the conversation. "Mmhmm," Edwin confirmed with a nod. "Nebraska, actually. Lots of cows and farms. Not really a large magic community though."

"So how did you end up in England?" Tabitha nudged.

"Oh, well I had been going to school in America, to the Ilvermorny School, actually. That's in Massachusetts. But you know, my dad's job needed him in England, so we moved." He said this with a shrug, as if adding "what are you gonna do?"

"Oh, I see," Tabitha said, before Maisie interrupted.

"Tabitha is from Ireland," she blurted out.

Edwin nodded. "I uh… gathered from the accent," he said sheepishly.

"Oh," Maisie said, her face scrunching into a confused pucker. "I didn't know Americans could tell the difference."

The train ride lasted most of the rest of the day, and by the time they arrived in Hogsmeade it was already dark. Leaving the train, the girls made their separate ways to groups of other students from their respective houses: Tabitha to Slytherin, Maisie to Hufflepuff. Edwin wasn't sorted into a house yet, so even though he was a sixth-year like them, he was still shuffled in with the first-years. He towered over them, looking more than a little ridiculous.

"Ladies! With me please!" A voice called over the muted conversations, and Tabitha wondered if it had been amplified slightly. "Slytherin upper-class ladies!" the voice called again, "follow me please!" Despite the polite "please", this was decidedly a command. The group of girls, a few dozen sixth- and seventh-year Slytherins, all began to follow, separating from the larger crowd. Ahead, Tabitha could see the black carriages, though not the Thestrals she knew were tied to them. Some could, she knew, but so far, she had the good fortune to still not be able to see or hear the beasts. Still, she felt a chill run down her spine as she passed where they must have been standing.

A few minutes later, Tabitha and the other girls stood inside the main entrance of the castle itself. All eyes and ears were on one girl, stood a few paces outside of the group, standing on a box she had conjured and holding the tip of a wand to her throat. She had introduced herself as Selene Blackspire, a seventh-year student and the House Steward. She was responsible, she said, for getting them acclimated. She had just gone through a very generic, very rehearsed speech welcoming them all back and reminding them of just how privileged they were to be attending the greatest wizarding school in the world, and to be members of the greatest house at that school. It was the same speech, more or less, that Tabitha had heard for the previous five years, and hardly worth her attention. The words seemed to flow in and back out of her head in a sonorous drone.

"Now," Selene said, a little sharply and with meaning. Tabitha's head snapped up. "As you all know, the upper class students, that is, the sixth- and seventh-years, have their own dormitory separate from the others. We are going to head there now, and quickly, because we need to prepare for the sorting ceremony. This way please." Selene stepped down from the box, which disappeared with a quick flick of her wand, then began what could only be called a march, leading the group deeper into the castle. Every girl in the group knew where the entrance to the common room was, though they dutifully followed Selene down into the dungeons and to the unassuming wall. Selene stopped, and Tabitha saw her lean close to the wall and whisper something she couldn't make out. "The password will be given out once we are all inside," Selene explained, as the passage began to open.

They all followed into the common room, now so familiar and, in its way, so welcoming. Many considered the space to be cold and even sinister. Tabitha, however, found a certain beauty in the intricate scrollwork of the columns and needlework of the carpets. Yes, it was cold and slightly damp, but there was always a large fire to keep those at bay. As she stepped inside, she breathed in the scent of firewood and of wet stone and of old leather. This was home to her, at times more so than the house in which she had been raised.

Selene, and the group of girls, crossed the spacious common room, turned a corner, and then stopped before a nondescript alcove. In fact, it stood out so little that it might as well have been invisible. Tabitha couldn't be certain she'd ever seen it before.

"Quickly, before the others come," Selene said, conspiratorially. "Watch," she instructed, then without another word, stepped into the alcove, and to her left, apparently directly through the stonework. Several of the girls gasped in surprise, but then giggled and laughed as Selene poked her head back out. "This way," she beckoned.

One by one, each girl stepped into the alcove, then took one more step to the left, disappearing just as Selene had. Only a few had trouble the first time, one banging her shoulder against the stone rather hard, and Tabitha was sure she would have a bruise there the next morning. She herself, at least, managed on the first try, stepping through the stone wall into a small space at the bottom of spiral stone steps. The girl before her was already a few steps up, and Tabitha followed.

She couldn't tell for sure, but the upper-class dorm had to be several stories above the common room, based on the number of stairs it took to get there. Then again, in a castle partially constructed out of pure magic, it was hard to say with any certainty.

Eventually, the stairs gave way to a small landing beyond which was a thick, wooden door. Carved into the wood was an intricate snake, curling over and around itself. It stood open for now, letting the girls into the room beyond.

The upper-class dorm was everything the common room was not: the colors were richer, deeper. The air was warm and comfortably dry. The lighting, while subdued, still added a further warmth to the atmosphere. This was the privilege afforded to the older girls; to the ones who had earned their place, and Tabitha loved it.

"Alright, there are no assigned beds, so choose whichever you want," Selene was saying, "and seventh-year girls get priority selection of their bed from last year if they wish. But don't take too long choosing. The sorting ceremony is in less than half an hour."

Tabitha's green eyes danced over the room as other girls moved to beds and claimed them. Realizing that she would miss out on her chance to choose herself, she made a quick inventory of the ones still left, picked one near a window, and went for it, sitting on the duvet to claim her territory. Less than a minute later, all of the girls had claimed a bed.

Selene stood in the middle of the room, surveying. When she saw that everyone had a place and was in it, she gave a quick nod. "Alright. We need to get going if we're to have any chance of making it to the ceremony on time." She made a sweeping gesture with her wand then, seemingly encompassing the entire room. As the tip passed her bed, Tabitha noticed a pile of clothes pop into existence next to her. "Alright, quickly, girls. Let's get dressed." Selene moved from the middle of the room, to the bed that had been saved specifically for her. Tabitha watched her go, and then watched her begin to undress.

Tabitha spent a few moments watching Selene remove her clothing before very suddenly realizing just what she was looking at. Tearing her eyes away, wanting to look anywhere else, her attention landed on another seventh-year girl, this one already topless, her breasts on display for anyone who would look. In fact, more and more girls, all seventh-years, were undressing, most to undergarments, some even farther. Tabitha looked to the sixth-years, who all shared looks of astonishment, confusion, a couple of amusement.

"Come on, girls, we don't have all night. We don't have changing rooms in the upper-class dorm." Selene, too, had removed her own bra and was facing the sixth-year girls, breasts proudly standing out on her chest. "They're just tits," she scolded mildly. "We all have them, get over it." One of the sixth-year girls giggled, then pulled her t-shirt up and off, displaying a confidence that Tabitha couldn't determine whether it was real, or induced by nerves. After a moment, a few of the others joined in on the communal undressing.

Tabitha looked at the bed, at the pile of clothes waiting for her: pleated beige skirt, white button-down blouse, green and silver tie with matching socks, and a black wizard robe with the Slytherin shield emblazoned on the chest. It was the same uniform she had worn all of her years at Hogwarts. She looked up then, to see Selene completely nude, wrapping the robe around herself and beginning to fasten it shut. "I can't stand muggle clothes," Selene explained, though Tabitha couldn't determine to whom.

By this time, all of the other girls were dressing, or at least in the last stages of undressing. Some had slipped into the skirts and blouses, one or two were following Selene's example and going commando beneath their robes. Tabitha knew that if she delayed the girls she could lose points for Slytherin even on that very first night. That, she couldn't allow.

Should Tabitha:

A: Slip the robe on over her everyday muggle clothes? Time is of the essence, and undressing in front of strangers is still outside of her comfort zone.

B: Change into the uniform skirt, blouse, tie, and the rest, then put on the robe? It is the uniform, after all, and she wouldn't have to take off her bra and underwear. They were clean… right?

C: Get out of her clothes but keep her bra and underwear on. Selene was on to something with her distaste for muggle clothes, but getting fully nude was a bridge too far, at least for now.

D: Strip nude then put the robe on. Fuck it. When in Rome…

I am sorry AGAIN! I'm still trying to figure out the best polling option. Now it looks like Google Forms is going to be it. Please find the poll below:

 
There was little time to waste. Tabitha quickly looked around the room: all of the other girls were changing, some undressing and putting on the full uniform, others stripping fully nude, following Selene's example. Others still were opting for something in the middle, undressing but still keeping undergarments on. None, however, were looking at her: each was occupied with her own clothing situation. That was what allowed her to finally get moving.
Mostly to blend in while still in the muggle world, Tabitha had opted for an unassuming outfit of jeans and a band t-shirt. She didn't even know who the band was, and probably didn't care for their style of music anyway, but those clothes were a costume, a disguise. In a single motion, her t-shirt was up and over her head, soon tossed at the foot of the bed next to the folded pile of uniform pieces. She kicked out of her shoes: a kind called "sneakers" that were comfortable, if not exactly attractive. The jeans were next, the wide black leather, double-buckled belt undone and the whole thing lowered from her hips to pool on the floor. She now stood only in a pair of pink cotton panties and decided-no-matching powder blue bra, the only remaining vestiges of her muggle costume. This was as exposed as she cared to be for now, maybe even more than she actually cared for, and she self-consciously wrapped her arms around herself, covering her stomach and somewhat hiding her breasts. Once more she looked around the room to make sure she wasn't being watched. Again, all eyes were elsewhere, all eyes except two.
Across the room and to her left, a pair of brown eyes examined her. Tabitha recognized the girl, knew her rather well actually. The eyes belonged to Vivienne Blackthorn, another girl in her year, one she'd known since they started at Hogwarts. They were friends, if not exactly best friends. Everything since arriving had been such a rush, other than Maisie on the train, there had been no time to catch up with friends.
Tabitha had expected Vivienne to look away once she was caught looking, but the girl didn't seem to react to being noticed. She just looked, just watched Tabitha watching her. Tabitha suddenly felt even more exposed, even more on display, than she had a moment ago, but she made no move to further cover herself. What could she possibly do with her arms to hide her body any more than she already was? Only then, moments after realizing she was being watched, did Tabitha notice that Vivienne herself was entirely nude.
Tabitha found her own eyes taking in the other girl's body. Vivienne had always been tall, a bit taller than Tabitha herself. Originally narrow and lanky, Vivienne had filled in over the years and now, while still slender, displayed generous and gentle curves in all of the right places. She didn't seem to be ashamed to show them off either: her breasts, moderate in size and immaculate in shape, stood proudly on her chest, little pink nipples stiff in the cool room. Her tummy was flat, with the suggestion of lines of definition starting to form at either side. Her pubic area was smooth, save for a small landing strip of dark hair just above her sex.
Tabitha realized that Vivienne was letting her look, maybe even wanted her to look. She certainly made no effort to hide herself. The moment was broken, though, when Vivienne tossed her Slytherin robe over her head and draped it down her body, finally covering herself. Only then did Tabitha snap out of it, and realize that she still wasn't dressed.
She stepped into the pleated khaki skirt first, fastening it at her left hip. The white button-down collared shirt came next, tucked into the skirt and with the top button left undone. Green and silver tie, then the matching socks and the black chunky-heeled shoes. Finally she slipped the robe on, and was ready to go, apparently just in time.
"Is everybody ready then?" Selene asked of the room as a whole. "Finally?" she added pointedly, not quite looking directly at Tabitha. There were nods and noises of agreement from mostly all. "Alright then. Follow me. I know you know the way, but let's all go as a group." Selene headed for the dorm door and the staircase beyond.
As Tabitha started to move with the crowd, she felt a presence to her side, someone moving in next to her. "Hi," came Vivienne's soft voice.
"Hey," Tabitha greeted back, not sure what else to say.
"I wanted to say hi to you ever since we arrived in Hogsmeade but haven't had a chance."
"Yeah it's been a little crazy," Tabitha agreed with a nod. They were just starting down the spiral stairs, shoulder-to-shoulder.
"I wanted to talk to you," Vivienne said after a moment. "Do you think we could get together after the ceremony?" Tabitha couldn't be sure, but had a suspicion that the talk had something to do with the look Vivienne had given her as they dressed.
"Um… yeah sure," Tabitha agreed, again with a nod, but one that she wasn't entirely confident in.
The great hall of Hogwarts was a large chamber, longer than it was wide and suitably sized to accommodate the whole student body. Tabitha had always suspected that it was able to grow, in one way or another, to accommodate however many people it needed to, and tonight was no exception. All seven years of all four houses filled the room, all seated on benches pulled up to long tables. Slytherin house still sat at the table closest to the doors from the entry hall, as they had done for… as long as anyone knew. Tabitha found a seat next to and across from a few other students, boys and girls, that she had known for some years, and they all exchanged hellos and meaningless banter. Vivienne had not tried to sit near Tabitha, finding a seat farther down the table, though her eyes occasionally made their way over to where Tabitha sat.
They were not late in arriving to the great hall. Even still, it was only a few minutes before the headmaster, Thaddeus MacDougal, started speaking. "First, I would like to take a moment to welcome back all of the returning students…" Tabitha hated speeches, and her attention started to wander, eventually landing on the table where the new students, all of them first-years, looked around in awe and wonder at their surroundings. Tabitha remembered her first time at Hogwarts, and was pretty sure she had looked exactly like them.
Of course, they weren't actually all eleven-year-old first-years: one stood out from the rest, conspicuously larger, taller, older. Edwin Stormspire, another sixth-year like herself, sat among the kids. Tabitha caught herself looking him over, noticing his dark hair and blue eyes, his boyish face that was just on the edge of becoming more grown-up. She found herself wondering if he could grow facial hair yet, and what he might look like with a beard, or a goatee. Really his face was all of him that she could make out: like the others, he wore a black wizard robe over his clothes, but without a house crest. He hadn't been sorted yet. That would come… soon.
In really only a few minutes, the old hat was brought out, and names were called. The hat announced houses, as it had for generations, as it had for Tabitha herself. She cheered for all of the new Slytherins, while also waiting with anticipation for what house Edwin would be sorted into. Might he also find himself in her own house, or would he find himself in one of the others? She didn't know enough of his personality to really say. When his time came, though, she felt her stomach knot. She tried to convince herself she didn't know why it would do that, but that was a lie.
Edwin made his way up to the stool and took a seat, an embarrassed grin on his face: he was the only older student who was being sorted, and while no one laughed, Tabitha saw more than one amused expression as she looked around the room. Vivienne had one of them.
"Ravenclaw!" the hat announced after a moment, and that house erupted in cheers. Tabitha sunk, and again tried to pretend not to know why. Why would she care what house a stranger was sorted into? And even if she did care, for some unknown reason, it wasn't like the houses never interacted. Really, they did so all the time. Sure, there was competition between them but… why did that matter again?
A few minutes later the sorting was done, and the students were dismissed back to their houses and their dorms. Tabitha rose and started making her way toward the doors, passing Vivienne on the way. As she did, she felt something brush against her hand, very gently, almost not even there. She looked to see what it was, saw nothing at first, the noticed Vivienne once again looking her way. A reminder that Vivienne wanted to talk after the ceremony? Probably, but here and now didn't seem to be the place. She gave the other girl a small smile of acknowledgement, but kept going.
The great hall emptied on the large entry hall, from which the student body would again separate into their houses and go their separate ways. At first, though, they had to each separate themselves out of a large, homogenous crowd. Tabitha was trying to do so, to make her way to the right and down the familiar passage, when she noticed Edwin. Actually, she noticed him just as he noticed her, and their eyes locked for a brief second that didn't feel brief at all. She saw him stop, and apparently try to make a decision about something. Did he want to talk to her?
"Tabitha!" A moment later, a second really, she heard her name being called by a familiar voice. She turned to see Maisie making a beeline through the crowd to her, ignoring and directly crossing the flow of foot traffic. The Hufflepuff girl could appear at the least-convenient times, though a thought occurred to Tabitha: she might be able to ask Maisie about what had happened earlier, the group enrobing and all of the nudity. Was that going on in Hufflepuff as well? Did that have something to do with what Maisie, and many others, had mentioned about the last two years at Hogwarts?

Who should Tabitha meet up with?
1. Vivienne. She was an old friend who clearly wanted something important, if mysterious.
2. Edwin. Tabitha was already starting to feel an attraction to him which she didn't think was romantic, but was… something.
3. Maisie. Tabitha had questions, and Maisie seemed to know more than she did.

 
Back
Top Bottom