AJ wasn't sure what made his heart twist more - the smile she gave him or the way her hands lingered over his own. It was that rare smile, the one that slipped past the careful mask she wore in front of her mother and the world. It was real. Unrestrained. It shone in her eyes and made him feel, just for a moment, like he was more than a man in uniform.
"Thank you," she whispered, and he felt it down to the bones of his fingers where her thumbs brushed his knuckles. He didn't answer her praise aloud. How could he? If he opened his mouth, he feared something truer might slip out - something that would ruin everything. So instead, he bowed his head slightly, allowing the ghost of a smile to touch the corner of his lips. Then, gently, he stepped back to regain some space, some clarity.
When she mentioned the delivery he'd referenced earlier, he shook his head with a slight smile. "It's nothing urgent. Mr. Rhodes will manage it himself. He only sent me because I happened to be nearby. You won't get me scolded, Miss Evelyn. Not today."
But when she said we, his heart faltered again. She always included him in things as though they were equals. As though he hadn't been born to a world of ledger books and disgrace, scraping coin from coin to survive after the collapse of everything his family had once been. Her father, of course, knew the details. Hired him anyway. Took pity, perhaps. Or saw a use in a boy who once studied Latin and arithmetic under private tutors but now folded shirts and polished boots. Evelyn had never once treated him as less. And that was both his greatest gift… and his torment.
"I'll ready the carriage," he said quietly, already moving with practiced ease, posture straightening as he slipped back into the role that life had handed him. He left her standing in the warm bustle of the kitchen and made his way through the manor halls with calm, efficient steps, though inside his thoughts raced. He was painfully aware of the weight her words had carried—not just the kindness in them, but the innocence. You've never let me get hurt on an outing before. She had no idea. No idea how every suitor, every passing week, was another cut to something he couldn't even name aloud.
Once outside, AJ gave quiet instruction to the stable hands and set the horses in place himself, polishing the brass on the harnesses with a cloth even though they already gleamed. It was habit, it was control. He needed something to do with his hands. By the time Evelyn appeared, cloaked and ready, he was composed again. Always composed. He helped her up into the carriage with a steady hand before taking his seat opposite her inside.
The ride into town passed through sun-dappled lanes and quiet meadows, the silence between them never uncomfortable. She spoke now and then - commenting on the early blooms along the roadside, the scent of the rain-washed earth. He answered when needed, his words careful but not cold. She spoke of errands, of needing a few items before the weekend, and he nodded.
"We'll stop at the dressmaker's first," he said, glancing out the window to ensure they'd beat the midday rush. "Then if you'd like, we can walk the market street. It'll be quieter today." When they finally arrived in town, AJ stepped down first and offered her his hand. "Watch the step, miss." He helped her down with a gentleness that belied the strength in his arms, and as her hand slipped from his again, he allowed himself one small look - just one. She was radiant in the morning light, cheeks touched with the slightest bloom from the cool air.
They walked through the square together, her just slightly ahead, speaking cheerfully to merchants and stopping to admire little trinkets. He trailed close behind, always present but never intrusive, responding when needed, shielding her from stray glances or too-curious townsfolk. Always the watchful shadow.
But inside his thoughts turned dark. This couldn't go on much longer. The more time they spent together, the harder it became to keep his emotions locked away. He knew the world would never let them be anything more. And he feared if he stayed, he might someday be forced to watch her walk down the aisle to another man - someone born into wealth and title, someone who would never know the way she crinkled her nose when thinking or how she adored the smell of baking bread over imported perfumes.
That night, AJ would lie awake, the soft sound of her laughter still in his ears. And he would decide.